The Ferguson Moment: Race and Place
The shooting of Michael Brown, an unarmed black teenager, by a white police officer in Ferguson, Missouri, set off a series of peaceful protests and violent riots that reverberated across the nation -- and even the world. The media has largely viewed the turmoil in Ferguson through a racial lens. A half century after the legislative triumphs of the civil rights movement it seems as if race relations are as bad as ever. And if old-fashioned racism drives the injustices in Ferguson, then the solutions are clear: enforce civil rights laws, register black voters, take power away from entrenched white political elites, and administer the law fairly.
These steps are necessary, of course, but they are not sufficient for addressing the racial injustices that were exposed by the turmoil in Ferguson.
What if blacks have the right to sit anywhere they want on the bus, but no bus runs past their home?
What if African Americans have the right to live anywhere they want regardless of skin color, but they can only afford places that suffer from high crime, underperforming schools, and shabby public spaces?
What if minorities have the right to vote, but their local government is a “hollow prize”: small, fiscally stressed, and lacking in professionalism?
What upholds racial inequality now is not so much person-to-person discrimination but the tangled web of race and class embedded in metropolitan development patterns.
In Place Matters: Metopolitics for the Twenty-First Century (3rd ed. 2014), we, along with co-author Peter Dreier, document the rise of concentrated poverty and metropolitan inequality. At the same time that black-white segregation has slowly declined (Logan and Stults, Glaeser and Vigdor), economic segregation has risen (Reardon and Bischoff; Pendall, et al). The growth of concentrated poverty is especially striking in the suburbs (Kneebone and Berube). The maps below show the growth of concentrated poverty outside the city of St. Louis in suburbs like Ferguson in St. Louis County.
Ferguson has a poverty rate of about 22 percent (2008-2012 ACS); on the eastern edge of the town, where the protests took place, the rate exceeds 33 percent. (Ferguson is hardly the poorest municipality in St. Louis County; in fact, 17 other municipalities have higher poverty rates.) With per capita assessed valuation at only about one-third of the County average, Ferguson is locked in a fiscal cage: if it increases tax rates (to raise revenues to meet needs), it will drive home values down further; but if it does not increase tax rates, it will slowly starve municipal services and the schools.
Fiscally stressed suburbs in St. Louis have tried to finesse this dilemma by turning to alternative sources of revenue. Amazingly, over one quarter of Ferguson’s budget comes from traffic fines and court fees. Systematic police and judicial practices in poor St. Louis suburbs are balancing their city budgets on the backs of their most vulnerable citizens (Balko; Arch City Defenders). Police issue tickets for everything from illegal turns, to driving without insurance, to loud music and “saggy pants.” When citizens fail to appear in court because they don’t have the cash to pay the fines, a warrant is issued for their arrest. In 2013, the Ferguson’s municipal court— serving a city of 21,135 people — issued 32,975 arrest warrants for nonviolent offenses. Trapped in an oppressive legal system without a lawyer, people often end up losing their right to drive, their jobs, and their freedom. With good reason, critics have compared it to debtors’ prisons.
Race adds to the toxic mix. Police systematically target those who look poor, often black people, because they know they are more likely to have an outstanding warrant – and arrest provides additional opportunities to pile on more court fees and fines. Add the fact that 50 out of 53 police officers in Ferguson were white (in a city that is two-thirds black) and you have an explosive situation that goes a long way toward explaining the anger that erupted in the protests and riots. Relatively poorly paid and poorly trained white police, who usually do not live in the community, treat peaceful citizens in a remarkably disrespectful – and sometimes, as in the case of Michael Brown, a remarkably brutal – manner.
Race is not the main driver of these oppressive practices. With an all-black city council, black mayor, and majority black police force, the nearby city of Berkeley engages in the same practices as Ferguson, last year generating $111 in traffic fines and court fees per resident and issuing 5,504 arrest warrants (Balko).
Whites are also harassed by distressed suburban municipalities. Since one of us (Todd) moved to St. Louis thirteen years ago, he has received a number of minor traffic violations with excessive fines from small municipalities. Todd’s solution is simple: He hires a lawyer; the lawyer plea bargains the ticket down to a nonmoving violation so there are no points against his driver’s license; he pays the lawyer about $120 and an inflated fine, say $150, and goes on with his life. It’s expensive but low stress. If you are poor and can’t afford a lawyer, however, you can be pulled down into a vortex of fines, arrest warrants, and even imprisonment.
To suggest, as the media and many activists do, that Ferguson’s turmoil is rooted in old-fashioned racism misses important points. Electing blacks to Ferguson’s city council and hiring more black police officers will help, but it will not address the underlying cause: the growth of concentrated poverty in the suburbs. Not only are the suburban poor isolated from opportunity, like the central city poor, but they also face weak governmental and civic institutions that deepen their disadvantage (Weir).
Addressing the underlying causes of the unrest in Ferguson will require changing the regional patterns of inequality. As we argue in Place Matters, the metropolitan playing field is tilted toward suburban sprawl and urban and inner suburban decline. Governments in the St. Louis region subsidize the flight of middle-class, largely white, families out of the older parts of the region by building highways rather than public transit and giving tax breaks for jobs to decentralize. Exclusionary zoning regulations that outlaw apartments or require large lots for single-family homes prevent poor families from following jobs to opportunity-rich suburbs. These laws need not mention race in order to promote racially disparate outcomes. Because of longstanding, state-sanctioned discrimination against African Americans in job markets and education, they tend to be poorer and therefore economic discrimination by exclusionary zoning effectively becomes racial discrimination.
Generals are notorious for “fighting the last war.” Our concern is that we will make the same mistake in responding to events in Ferguson. In fact, the passage of civil rights laws ended the last war; we won the battle against state-sanctioned racial discrimination. Listening to the coverage of events in Ferguson would make you believe that the civil rights movement failed – that people are as racist as ever. No doubt subtle and subconscious racism still exists. But the underpinnings of racial injustices today are metropolitan development patterns rooted in a tangled complex of private practices and public policies. We need new strategies and tactics for a new war.
Arch City Defenders, Municipal Courts White Paper, https://www.dropbox.com/s/vwptqn3mhq9xvy7/ArchCity%20Defenders%20Municipal%20Courts%20Whitepaper.pdf.
Balko, Radley, “How Municipalities in St. Louis County, MO., Profit From Poverty,” http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2014/09/03/how-st-louis-county-missouri-profits-from-poverty/.
Dreier, Peter, John Mollenkopf, and Todd Swanstrom, Place Matters: Metropolitics for the Twenty-First Century, 3rd edition (Lawrence, Kansas: University Press of Kansas, 2014).
Ed Glaeser and Jacob Vigdor, “The End of the Segregated Century: Racial Separation in America’s Neighborhoods, 1890-2010,” Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, Civc Reprot 66, January 2012, http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/cr_66.htm.
Elizabeth Kneebone and Alan Berube, Confronting Suburban Poverty in America (Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press, 2013).
Logan, John R and Brian Stults, The Persistence of Segregation in the Metropolis: Findings from the 2010 Census, Census Brief prepared for Project US2010, 2011, http://www.s4.brown.edu/us2010/Data/Report/report2.pdf.
Rolf Pendall, et al, A Lost Decade: Neighborhood Poverty and the Urban Crisis of the 2000s, Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies, September 2011, http://jointcenter.org/research/lost-decade-neighborhood-poverty-and-urban-crisis-2000s.
Sean F. Reardon and Kendra Bischoff, Growth in the Residential Segregation of Families by Income, 1970-2007 Project US2010, November 2011, http://www.s4.brown.edu/us2010/Data/Report/report111111.pdf.
Weir, Margaret, “Creating Justice for the Poor in the New Metropolis,” in Clarissa Hayward and Todd Swanstrom, eds., Justice and the American Metropolis (Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 2011), pp. 237-256.